AITA for Not Sharing Anything with My Son?

Feeling like YATA for Check out our quick advice if you really are or not. But before that, let's read first a similar story to reflect on from .

It all began years ago when my son, Jake, was just a kid. I had always prided myself on being a self-made man.

I’d started a small business from scratch, worked tirelessly to make it successful, and eventually, it did well enough that I could provide a comfortable life for my family.

However, throughout this journey, I had this mindset that I wanted Jake to learn the value of hard work and earn everything he had in life, just like I did. I didn’t want to hand him things on a silver platter.

That’s where the issue began.

The Situation

Early Lessons in Responsibility

When Jake was around 12 years old, he began showing interest in getting a car. It was a natural desire, but I insisted that he must work for it. I made him do odd jobs around the house and encouraged him to save his allowances.

He spent summers mowing lawns and winters shoveling driveways in our neighborhood. I thought this would teach him valuable lessons about work ethic and financial responsibility.

Financial Independence

As he grew older and expressed interest in college, I told him that he needed to find a way to pay for it himself. I had managed to put myself through school, and I believed he could too.

So, he started working part-time jobs while attending high school and saved up for tuition. I was proud of him for working hard to achieve his dreams, but this insistence on financial independence strained our relationship.

Home Ownership

By the time Jake reached his early twenties, he had managed to graduate debt-free.

However, when he mentioned he wanted to buy a house, I stood my ground once again. I refused to provide any financial assistance, explaining that he needed to save, invest, and buy a house through his own efforts.

I had bought my first house without any help, and I believed he could do the same.

No Inheritance

Throughout these years, I also made it clear that I didn’t intend to leave him a substantial inheritance.

My wealth was hard-earned, and I wanted him to establish his own legacy. I didn’t want to spoil him with financial comfort.

The Breaking Point

Recently, Jake’s car broke down, and he faced some unexpected medical expenses. He reached out to me for help, and I declined, explaining that he should have had an emergency fund for situations like this.

He seemed hurt and frustrated, and it became clear that our relationship was strained beyond repair.

Am I the Asshole?

So, am I the asshole for not sharing anything with my son?

It’s a tough question, and I’ve had sleepless nights thinking about it. On one hand, I genuinely wanted to teach him the value of hard work and financial responsibility. I believe these lessons shaped me into the person I am today.

On the other hand, my strict approach has strained our relationship, and it’s evident that he feels I should have been more supportive.

It’s essential to strike a balance between teaching independence and providing support, and I wonder if I failed to find that balance.

In retrospect, I wonder if I could have been more flexible and empathetic toward my son’s needs and struggles. Maybe, in my quest to toughen him up, I failed to acknowledge the emotional toll it was taking on him.

As I reflect on my actions, I can’t help but wonder if I might have been too harsh.

But, I also can’t shake the belief that I was doing what I thought was best for him. T

he question lingers: Am I the asshole?

Leave a Comment

Skip to content