AITA for Checking Out of Parental Duties?

Feeling like YATA for Check out our quick advice if you really are or not. But before that, let's read first a similar story to reflect on from .

It’s a question that has been gnawing at me for months, and I find myself awake at night, wondering if I’m the asshole for even considering it. I’m a 37-year-old father of two beautiful children, Mia, who’s 9, and Ethan, who’s 7.

My wife, Sarah, and I have been together for 15 years, and we’ve always tried to be good parents. But lately, I’ve been feeling overwhelmed, and I can’t help but question whether I should check out of some of my parental duties.

The Happy Family

Before all this turmoil started, we were what most people would call the “perfect family.” Sarah and I had a loving relationship, and we were always there for our kids. We took family vacations, spent time playing board games, and attended all their school events. But as the kids got older, life got busier, and the pandemic hit, things began to change.

The Breaking Point

The breaking point came when I lost my job due to the pandemic, while Sarah’s workload skyrocketed as a nurse on the front lines. Suddenly, I was thrust into the role of stay-at-home dad. While I appreciated the time with my children, it quickly became apparent that I was not cut out for this.

Homeschooling, meal preparation, and managing the household left me frazzled, and I began to resent my wife for her long hours at work.

The Proposal

One day, I made a radical proposal. I told Sarah that I couldn’t handle the parenting duties anymore and suggested hiring a live-in nanny. My argument was that this would free up my time to find a new job and bring some much-needed balance to our lives. I reasoned that with a professional caregiver on board, the kids would still be well cared for, and I could contribute financially to the household.

My Justification

I justified my proposal by saying that I wasn’t shirking all responsibilities. I’d still be there for the kids emotionally, but I couldn’t be the primary caregiver anymore. I needed time to pursue my own dreams, which had taken a backseat for years. It seemed fair to me – I was essentially redistributing the parenting load to make it more equitable.

Sarah’s Reaction

Sarah was shocked by my suggestion. She argued that our children needed their parents, not a stranger, to be there for them during these formative years. She was also hurt, feeling that I was trying to escape the hard work of parenting just when she needed my support the most. We had numerous heated arguments about this, and it seemed like we were at an impasse.

The Dilemma

As the weeks went by, my dilemma deepened. I couldn’t help but wonder if I was the asshole for even considering checking out of some of my parental duties. My friends and family had mixed reactions, and I was torn between my own needs and my responsibilities as a father.

The Kids

Mia and Ethan were caught in the middle of our arguments. They were used to me being more hands-on with their daily routines, and the idea of a stranger stepping in was met with resistance. They missed me, and I could see the emotional toll it was taking on them.

Financial Stress

The pandemic had put a significant strain on our finances. With me out of work and Sarah’s income stretched thin, money was a constant source of tension. I believed that if I could find a job, it would alleviate some of the financial pressure. But Sarah worried that the cost of a live-in nanny would only add to our expenses.

Personal Fulfillment

I also felt a strong desire for personal fulfillment. I had dreams and aspirations that had taken a backseat to my role as a parent. While I understood that parenthood required sacrifices, I couldn’t help but wonder if it was fair to sacrifice my own happiness and ambitions for the sake of my family.

Am I the Asshole?

So, am I the asshole for considering checking out of some of my parental duties? It’s a question that plagues me every day. On one hand, I believe I’m trying to find a way to contribute to my family financially, ease our financial stress, and pursue my own dreams.

On the other hand, I understand that parenting is a lifelong commitment, and I don’t want to abandon my children when they need me the most.

I can’t help but feel torn between what I see as my own needs and the needs of my family. So, I leave it to you, the readers, to weigh in on this situation. Am I the asshole for wanting to hire a live-in nanny and take a step back from some of my parental duties, or am I justified in seeking a more balanced approach to our family life?

Leave a Comment

Skip to content